ideas that come and go
February 24, 2012 by

Pinterest = Lack of Interest

Does anyone else think that the layout for Pinterest is just too cluttered? I’m a little surprised I haven’t read much from people who champion “Lean UX” about Pinterest.

Sure this may be just a guy’s opinion, but come on. Upon loading the site, I’m bombarded with tons, I mean tons of images that people have pinned, each with its own running comment thread. What do you call this sort of layout? A collage? I call it Organized Chaos!

For me, there’s so much going on, I don’t know where to start or what to do. The signup process was also particularly odd. I was asked to select some of my “interests” and out popped recommendations of people to follow. Now I’m okay with that, but can you at least tell me what makes this person the person to follow? Maybe in my haste, I missed that. Or maybe that’s not important.

Just as puzzling is how difficult it is for me to get a list of whom I’m following. Sure the homepage is filled with stuff from Pinners I follow, but who’s on that list? It’s possible that Pinterest wants to be agnostic in this respect, but then why even bother asking me to link Facebook and follow my friends? In the end, it must be because I’m a guy, and I just don’t get it.

  •   •   •   •   •
February 12, 2012 by

Guided Search

Here’s a simple idea that surprisingly I’ve yet to see implemented. On major sites like Amazon and Newegg, searching for a product gives you a guided search bar, which helps narrow down what you’re looking for. For each category, you can only pick one option. The idea is this: allow me to eliminate categories that I want excluded, in effect letting me pick more than one option.

For example, if I’m looking for running shoes, allow me to “cross out” Puma and leave Nike, Adidas, and Asics. It’s really that simple. Sometimes when I search for things, I know exactly what I don’t want and not necessarily what I do want. If I had only selected Nike, I may very well miss that new Asics shoe that works better for me.

Edit: Here’s a different example that might be better. Say I’m looking for music. Let’s take Jazz for example, and I’m interested in the record label Impulse. So I search “impulse records” on Amazon and out pops a bunch of albums under a ton a different genres. Wouldn’t it be nice to eliminate the categories for which I have no interest, allowing me the opportunity to explore the rest? Obviously, I could go category by category, but that’s way more tedious and takes away from the buying and exploration experience.

  •   •   •   •   •